.png){kind=small}
.png){kind=small}
.png){kind=small}
.webp)
There’s a lot of online debate lately about seed oils — think canola, soybean, corn, safflower, sunflower — with some voices insisting they’re harmful, inflammatory, or worse than butter. But recent large‐scale studies suggest otherwise. Let’s dive into what the evidence says, how seed oils compare to butter, and what you might consider doing in your diet.
What Are Seed Oils, and Why Are They Under Scrutiny?
- Seed oils are plant oils extracted from seeds (e.g. canola, soybean, corn, safflower). They are used in cooking, salad dressings, packaged foods, and so on.
- Critics point to concerns about:
- High omega-6 fatty acids → possible inflammation
- Processing (like refining, use of solvents)
- Misuse in ultra-processed foods
- But nutrition scientists say much of the alarm may come from context: what seed oils are compared to, how much is used, and what else is in the diet. Studies now are more carefully isolating those variables.
What the New Research Finds
Some of the most compelling recent findings:
- A large cohort study of 221,000+ adults over 30+ years showed people with higher butter intake had higher total and cancer mortality, while those with higher plant-based oil intake had lower total, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality.
- Swapping about 10 grams of butter per day (less than a tablespoon) with plant oils like canola, soybean, or olive oil was associated with about a 17% reduction in total mortality and similar reduction in cancer mortality.
- Seed oils have also been shown to lower LDL cholesterol compared to saturated fats like butter, lard, and beef tallow.
- The omega-6 concerns: While overconsumption of certain fats is an issue, studies do not strongly support the idea that usual dietary levels of omega-6 from seed oils are harmful or inherently inflammatory. Instead, the problem often is diets high in processed foods, added sugars, and saturated fats.
Seed Oils vs Butter: What’s the Difference?
What This Means for Your Diet
Here are practical takeaways based on the current evidence:
- Focus on what you replace – replacing butter or other high saturated fats with plant oils seems to bring the benefit, not just adding more oil.
- Choose quality oils – extra virgin olive oil, less refined oils, good storage matter. Heat stability matters depending on cooking method.
- Balance fat types – while seed oils are mostly unsaturated, make sure you’re also getting enough omega-3s (from fish, flax, walnuts) and limiting saturated fats.
- Watch overall diet pattern – processed foods, high sugar, excessive calories, sedentary lifestyle can overshadow benefits from switching fats.
Limitations & What We Still Don’t Know
- Most studies are observational: they show associations, not definitive cause & effect.
- Diet questionnaires can be imprecise. People who eat more plant oils might also do other things (eat more vegetables, exercise, etc.) that contribute to their health.
- The type of seed oil (refined vs unrefined), how it's processed, how it's used in cooking (high heat vs low heat) can alter health effects.
FAQ: Seed Oils and Health
Q: Are seed oils inflammatory?
No strong evidence that seed oils (in typical dietary amounts) cause systemic inflammation in healthy people. Omega-6 fatty acids are essential, and many studies show benefits.
Q: Should I stop using seed oils?
Not necessarily. If you're using large amounts of butter or saturated fats, replacing some with seed oils may improve health metrics. But moderation & variety are key.
Q: Which seed oils are best?
Olive oil, canola oil, soybean oil are among those showing benefits in studies. Unrefined versions tend to retain more beneficial compounds.
Q: Does using seed oils in processed food negate their benefits?
Potentially yes. The problem is often the processing, added sugars, frying at high heat, trans fats, etc. Seed oils in whole food settings (dressings, sautéing, roasting) are generally a better context.
The Bottom Line
While seed oils have been the target of many criticisms, recent large-scale research suggests that when used instead of saturated fats like butter, they are associated with lower risk of premature death, cardiovascular disease, and cancer. The fears about omega-6, inflammation, or processing are often overstated or lack strong human evidence.
If you want to make a healthful change, swapping modest amounts of butter with plant oils (like canola, soybean, olive) might be one of the easiest, evidence-based adjustments you can make.
Want personalized dietary advice? Request an appointment with a provider at BASS Medical Group to see what fats and oils work best with your health goals.
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)